Sunday, October 2, 2011

Why Study?

This is an article that I recently wrote for my school juniors, to be published in a souvenir that my school (De Paul School, Berhampur, Odisha) is bringing out on the occasion of its Silver Jubilee. You are requested to think from the perspective of a high school student (Class 9-10) while reading this article.

I happened to come across a TEDx talk by Simon Sinek, the author best known for developing The Golden Circle and popularizing the concept of Why, that inspired me to write this article. Simon narrated this interesting story:
All of us know the Wright Brothers - the men credited with inventing and building the world's first successful airplane. But most of us do not know Samuel Pierpont Langley. In the late 19th/early 20th century, when building a powered flight was a hot topic of research and development, Samuel Pierpont Langley had everything of what we assume is the recipe for success. He had money; he was given $50000 by the War Department to design a powered airplane (that would have been more than 24 lakhs Indian Rupees today; this ofcourse was sometime around 1900). He had a seat at Harvard and the Smithsonian institution, and had access to the best infrastructure and facilities available during those times. He hired the best minds and the best talent that money could find to work for him. The New York Times used to follow him around everywhere, and everyone was looking up to him to make this 'flying machine'. Then how come we have never heard of Samuel Pierpont Langley?

A few hundred miles away were the Wright Brothers - Orville and Wilbur. They had none of what Langley had. They had no money; they paid for their dreams from the earnings from their bicycle shop. Not a single person in their team had college education, not even Orville or Wilbur. The New York Times followed them nowhere. But they were driven by a cause - a belief that if they could figure out this flying machine, it will change the course of the world. Samuel Pierpont Langley was different; he wanted to be rich, he wanted to be famous. The people in Langley's team worked for the result - the riches. Those with Wright Brothers worked for the cause - the belief. And eventually, on December 17, 1903, the Wright Brothers took flight. And for proof that Langley was motivated by the wrong things, here's the most shocking fact - the day the Wright Brothers took flight, Langley quit! He could have said, “That's an amazing discovery, guys! Now let's improve upon this technology.” But he didn't. He wasn't first, he didn't get famous, so he quit! Despite having the money, the infrastructure, the resources, Langley couldn't be successful.
This made me realize that we, as students, are often motivated by the wrong things, just like Langley. We often make the mistake of pursuing the result; we study because we want to score 100%, we want to win the first prize, we want to be the topper wherever we go. And we go mad in our pursuit of the result. We resort to rote learning. We follow the herd to attend all kinds of tuitions. We do whatever it takes to reach the top. And as a result, in this crazy world of competition, we don't find a breathing space to actually enjoy our studies.

The real fun of education lies in appreciating its significance and learning its practical uses (and by practical use, I don't mean scoring marks in exams). Every subject that we learn in the classroom has something useful to teach us, something that aids us in understanding this world and this universe better, something that makes us a more capable person. We need to realize and appreciate this "something", only then can we understand the significance of what we are learning, and only then can we love our subjects and have the right motivation to study them.

How often do we bother to figure out the importance of what we learn in classrooms? We study History - the ancient age, the medieval period, the modern world; but how many of us can answer why we study all of that? Just because it's part of the curriculum? Nah, that can't be the only reason! We study Chemistry - we balance chemical equations, we write oxidation and reduction reactions, we study properties of compounds - but why? Do we know if those things really matter in this world? We study Mathematics - we learn set theory, we solve quadratic equations, we multiply matrices - but do we really know how and where these things can be of any use in life? If not, then why are we studying them in the first place? Just because our parents send us to school and our teachers give us homework? Is that our only motivation?

The trick to enjoying our subjects lies in finding the right motivation. And nothing can be a better motivation than a reason to love our subjects. It might be a tad unfortunate that we get to choose to study the subjects of our choice only after Class 10 or beyond, which means that until Class 10, we are constrained to study the subjects and topics that are prescribed for us by someone else, whether we like them or not. But with the good belief that our curriculum has been designed by wise and experienced people to impart us all-round education, we must find the right motivation to study within these constraints. Whenever we study a topic or a chapter, we must try to figure out its practical significance, or its conceptual elegance, or any other good reason to love the subject, and that will help us in enjoying our studies - and that, my dear friends, will automatically spur us to do well.

So the next time you attend any class, make sure you know why you're studying whatever you're studying. When your teacher asks you to write an official letter in a Language class, know that the exercise is to make you improve your letter-writing skills, as you'll be required to write a lot of important letters (emails) in your professional career. When your teacher explains you the world regions in a Geography class, know that it is to make you appreciate the differences in culture, landscape, social life and other aspects that exist among the different regions, so that you can comfortably interact and collaborate with people of different nationalities later on in your professional life if and when the need arises. When your teacher explains Total Internal Reflection in a Physics class, know that the phenomenon is something that forms the backbone of optical fibers and the internet, and is something without which you couldn't have checked your emails or used Facebook or chatted online with friends. When your teacher makes you study something which you really don't know why you should be studying, dare to ask, because unless you know it, you can't love the chapter, you can't have the right motivation to study. Studying just because you need to score good marks is like pursuing the result, like Samuel Pierpont Langley did; studying for the love of the subjects is like pursuing the cause, like the Wright Brothers did - the choice is yours.

I am reminded of these lines by Robert Frost that I had learnt in the holy premises of De Paul in Class 8 (way back in 2001-02), and which, I must admit, have had an indelible impact on the way I have looked at life and work ever since.
  
But yield who will to their separation,
My object in living is to unite
My avocation and my vocation
As my two eyes make one in sight.
Only where love and need are one,
And the work is play for mortal stakes,
Is the deed ever really done
For heaven and the future's sakes.
(Two Tramps in Mud Time, st. 9)

45 comments:

Anonymous said...

Loved it . Especially the last verse. Have been realizing this a lot in brm's class when he pauses to explain the reasons for teaching a particular concept. Wonderful article :)

kripal said...

Firstly as a graduate engineer, I am moved by whatever you have written. Loved it and each and everything you talked about is real and valid. As a school going kid , I wish I had someone like you to show the real meaning of education. There is a purpose for everything that we do and everything that happens to us. I didn't realize the real reason why I should study when I was a school going kid although I did well. I didn't realize this while I was pursing engineering at least not until my second year and I did not do that well in college. However, after my second year the reason dawned on me . Why m I studying differential equations ? ...what is the point in talking about vector space ... are these things relevant to me ... am I affected by any of these things. Slowly I realized that yes we are affected by what we study and there is a reason why we study what we study. its a great article. I would ask for your permission to include in my webpage :)

Kripal Lakhi

Sunaina said...

A highly motivational one! I will start applying this technique and get back to you with results soon :)Thanks for sharing!

Rakesh Misra said...

@ CJR Bharath: Completely agree about BRM! :-)

@Kripal ji: Lovely words! :-) It would be my privilege if you could spread my message on your website. :-) Thanks! :-)

@Sunaina: And I will be eagerly waiting to hear about your results. :-)

Kirtika said...

I really liked your article, *now* when I am in a position where I understand and appreciate the significance of what you say. However, would I feel the same about it as a school student?

Not just any school student, one among those middle class students in India who like education and knowledge but are not free to do what they want to do with it, because they have a system to adhere to. A system which guarantees them a good life only if they score 98%, get into IIT etc etc. For in India, most people think of education as a means to a trophy job and a better life. Economic betterment, though not always the sole driver, is still the major reason why the majority pays attention to education. And unfortunately, that economic betterment usually comes if you stick to the system - get 9x.xx % in the boards, get into an IIT/IIM, pick up some high-paying and focus on beating/gaming the system to be at the top of the competition rather than learning for the heck of it. Because no system rewards knowledge for the heck of it- the Board exam question setters don't care if I understand why I am studying 5000yr old civilizations. They care whether I know the death-year of some stupid Egyptian king. And not remembering that death-year could cost me a 0.01% and hence a seat at the college of my dreams, if I were in Delhi University. Reminds me of Chetan Bhagat's short story. Sigh.

Vasuki said...

Lovely article :-) Something I can totally relate to. Also while reading the article, I could hear your voice and how you would read it out :-)

K V R Sritej said...

Awesome article man..... But i wanna point out a few points to u... Nw that we are on the edge of engineering we actually know that there is a meaning to what we studied as kids and hence we can start relating to them.... But imagine when we are jus 12-14 years old... We jus dont have anythin to look at at that point of time to teach us abt the practicality of what we are learning.... Take me for example ... I had wondered how the heck did internet work way back in my 6th class but had no idea hw to start abt finding my answer nor someone who cud explain it to me..... It was oly after 8 years that a really managed to find out the real answer and that too oly cos i was still keen on finding it .... So i would really love to somehow find a way in which we can reach out to those small kids about how to learn ... Oly then do i feel we can actually achieve the concept of making them realise marks are the least of their concerns in life.... :) But i ve to say one thing ... reading Robert Frost again sure brought back loads of sweet memories :) And with regards to studying ... lets jus say i still have the enthu to go back to school and learn up everything again (which might happen if those CERN guys discover particles faster than light :D)

R Arun Srivatsan said...

Misro, golden words. Very very true. U wont believe it but last summer I spent a month reading 2 of my school geography books; cos they made more sense to me now. I never appreciated them back in school, though I managed to get good marks in them; but now I realize that they were useful and could have been interesting to read had I looked at them that way. Infact I am sure none of us paid any attention to what the chief guests spoke during an annual day or independence day. But I am sure they too would have said said similar things; just that as kids we had no interest in listening to them or appreciating them. Wish I could go back and forth in time; I would surely be a much better person in life today than what I am.

Ankit Behura said...

Really really inspiring... a great advice to persue whatever you like. I can truly relate to it... great post.. :-)

Chappli said...

Misra, true words! :) It's the same thing as what Lord Krishna says in the Bhagavad Gita, "Karmanyevadhikaarasthe, Maa Phaleshu Kadhachana", meaning "Do your duty, thoughtless of the fruit." Here, I believe doing something 'coz we like to, or because we know what we're doing would amount to doing our duty!

Well, sometimes, at some level, I'd also take the word of people to say that what we're doing might not be understood by us right now, but the relevance would come at a later time. But, as long as that enlightenment is there, and you know what you're doing relative to where you're placed right now, you hold yourself in good stead! :-) Nevertheless, a very nice and a relevant article for today! :)

Aditya Gudipati said...

So very true. I feel the idea of "enjoying education" and in general "enjoying work" is lost on many people, not just the 12-14 year olds. What you say about understanding the use of what we learn is a valid point.
However, my personal opinion is we should be able to appreciate education even without knowing the practical use of it. For example, when I first read about total internal reflection, I had no clue whatsoever that this concept forms the backbone of internet infrastructure!!! But it was intriguing nevertheless, the idea that light rays could bend at various angles based on the density of matter totally changed my perception of the world!!! It is this feeling of amazement and intrigue that drives me even today ... not because of their use.

I feel a major reason that such things fail to capture students' imagination in general is the pressure of performance and competition!! I remember how at the end of the year, people used to discuss about percentages and how person A beat person B by 0.5% !!! Such behavior is due to the goals set by their parents and teachers -- "you shud be in the top 5 in class", etal. A similar idea was conveyed by the movie "3 Idiots".

Prasanna said...

The article had a very feel-good feeling as I was reading it because they were very much the realisations that I have been having in the past 3 to 4 years. But would a high-school kid really understand the whole essence behind it ...

Then I saw Kirtika's comment. I couldn't agree more. There has to be something done about how our society views education.

And about the story of the Wright Brothers, I'm sure there are lots of other stories / conspiracies / scandals where the actual deserving person was never given credit and someone else stole the show (generally, the Nobel Prize :P)

But all said and done, I feel it is somewhat like .... people talk to small kids and tell them how to behave and why to behave like that even though they might not understand the reasons. But still, everyone would agree that by not doing it we are definitely missing out on subconsciously programming the child to grow up the right way. So such articles would definitely stay in the minds of children somewhere somehow and will have an effect.

Abhijeet said...

Very nice article! loved it! Some (supposedly) wise person has said "success is a journey not a destination"...However, there's a matter of relativity here - when you're a kid and you're taught things which don't seem to have obvious *practical* uses - it is impossible to enjoy them unless you have a good guide...That being the case, I think its very important to have at that time in your life a *desire to succeed* (even at the cost of your enjoyment). When you don't really know what to appreciate and what your interests are - its wise to learn as much as you can - by whatever means necessary so that you'd be wiser (or rather have *gained more information*) when you make choices later in life. There the motivation doesn't really matter (a score may disagree with me here :D). In my opinion, the situation as a grad/under-grad is very different =) You are presented with choices because you're assumed to be wise enough to make the right one. There you know what to appreciate, what matters is why you appreciate it. If one learns to enjoy (somehow) things early in his life...no doubt he has potential to do great things...however if he's doesn't he can still be passionate towards some goal (e.g. being on top of things) and potentially be great!

Sathish said...

First of all, not all curricula are designed to give someone an all-round education, like how many schools give music lessons? And, the students are still not free to fail, in a certain sense. Doing what you love is totally different from forcing yourself to love what you do. Sure, I appreciate History as it shows us patterns of human behaviour which we can keep in the back of our heads when we interact with people. But, it's ok to not love your studies, and goof around a bit. That point is lost in our school system which suggests only one way of coming up in life i.e. acads->marks->sexy college->job.

Arun said...

I was about to tell what G Vignesh told earlier- 'Do your duty. Do not worry about the results" - Gita. Fortunately enough, I had this question in mind of finding out what the implications of the things that I am studying could be and that kept me going on :-). The story of Wright brothers should be added in their GK/Moral science books.

Jasaswee Das said...

Nice article. The Indian perception of true and fruitful education is distorted. Students attending classes merely for the sake of attendance, one-night stands before the exam, copying assignments (nothing comes of it, except GPA) etc. Inquisitiveness is suppressed by the zeal to merely score marks. The situation in India is in sharp contrast to the one in US, where education is something exciting. In one of my Geotechnical engineering classes at UT Austin, the professor plays music relevant to the subject, then tries to draw parallels to the lyrics and tune. Every technical aspect here is interpreted from a layman's point of view with physical significance to the real world. Needless to say, students do not bunk classes. Classes here are such a delightful play. I do not see any such paradigm shift happening in India in the near future.

Navneet Kapur said...

There are two ways to do it right, in my opinion. One, you see a need - a genuine one (money is not a need - it comes if you work hard and are not too unlucky) - and you work towards it. The second - you just love puzzle-solving, Math for example - you like the ways numbers play around with each other. You don't know why you need those tricks but you just enjoy them. Or, you just enjoy knowing your culture or history - just for the heck of it. :) This way is more idealistic.

The funny and the sad part about education in India is that there is just too much to know (at least from a civic perspective - history, geography etc). Finding out why you need to know something is difficult and, at times, not possible. Because of this, the second option is what works if anything. If something doesn't work for anyone, they should try to do what Rakesh suggests here. ASK!! Never shy of asking. One of my teachers said: 'Jisne ki sharam, uske footey karam!' :)

Knowing what you want in life is not bad. Just remember that money never distinguishes you enough. Its that something else that we have to figure out - its what Coelho calls 'destiny'. Education is one of the best ways to find out what you are good at. Always give it a good shot.

Rakesh Misra said...

@Kirtika: Thanks a lot for those comments! :-) There are two broad solutions w.r.t. improving the scenario at the school level.
(1) Find a better education system.
(2) Find a better way within the existing education system.

(1) is a long-term solution, and might be complicated to work out. In this article, however, I have talked only about (2).

As I mentioned in the article, until atleast Class 10, we are constrained to learn and study what has been prescribed for us by our respective boards. We are constrained to go through examinations, because our performance holds the key to economic betterment in the future. We are constrained to compete with our peers so as to rise to higher and higher levels. The question that I am trying to answer via this article is: Given that we face all these constraints which inevitably come with our existing education system, what is the best that we can do? Can't we do any better than studying just for the sake of doing well in exams? Can't we do any better than considering acads as something that is forcefully thrust upon us? Of course, we can!

The idea of the article is NOT to make the school students so idealistic that they start studying just for the sake of their love for the subjects. The idea, as we discussed over chat, is to reduce the general dislike for acads. Of course, the students would still need to rote a lot of things, go through old questions/model exams etc as before so as to keep up with the demands of the existing system, but all of that will be more fun if they know what and why they're studying - and that, essentially, is the essence of this article. :-)

Rakesh Misra said...

@Vasuki: Thanks! :-) When I wrote this article, I was actually visualizing that I'm addressing my school juniors during the morning assembly, may be that's why it's more in the form of a speech. ;-)

@Sritej: Nice comment! I completely agree with you on the point that the school students are not mature or experienced enough to figure out by themselves the significance of all that they are studying - and this is where good teaching comes into the picture. At the school level, the onus is more on the teachers to point out the beauty/utility of the topics than on the students to find those out themselves. But the least that the students can do is to be on the lookout for the significance of what they are learning, and most importantly, cultivate the habit of asking Why and How for everything that they come across.

@Arun Srivatsan: Very true! Even I have discovered in the recent years the importance of so many things that I had learnt in school! :-)

@Ankit: Thanks! :-)

Rakesh Misra said...

@Chappli aka GV: True! :-) To translate your comment for the context of this article, as long as the school students know that what they are studying is not useless outside of exams, they stand in good stead. :-)

@Gudi: I agree! I should have made myself clearer - it's not always about the practicality alone. The underlying driving force for studying has to be a reason to love whatever you're studying. Knowing the practical uses might be one such reason, but not the only one. Getting intrigued by the nature of the concept can be another, like you mentioned. Most abstract mathematicians love their work for the beauty and elegance that is involved in logic, numbers and equations, which again are other possible reasons to love your subjects. It's fine as long as you are able to find a good reason for yourself. :-)

And thanks for mentioning about 3 Idiots. I actually wanted to quote a line from that movie: Kamyaab nahi, kaabil hone ke liye padho....kamyaabi jhak maarke pichhe aa jayegi (Study not to become successful but to become capable; success will automatically come your way). :-)

Rakesh Misra said...

@Prasanna: Thanks! :-) A high-school kid may not understand by himself the essence of all that we are discussing here, but he'll certainly give it a thought if someone points it out to him. Please also have a look at my response to Kirtika's comments.

@Abhijeet bhaina: Interesting perspective! I agree with you on the opinion that everyone should have a desire to succeed, but I would still say that not having the right motivation to study is not a good idea because it's very easy then to be caught off-guard by the pressure of academics and competition. As you suggested over chat, I guess I need to read Outliers for appreciating this different perspective. :-)

@Sathish: I agree that our education system is not truly all-round. But as I replied to Kirtika above, our discussions are in the context of case (2) and NOT (1), and therefore, we are only talking about what best can be done to improve the academic experience of the students under the given constraints. We should also start thinking about what we can do about (1), i.e. to improve the existing education system in India.

Monika said...

Awesome one.It actually reminds me of a lecture by my dad when i had flunked in my Social studies exam.. It was really hard to appreciate things at that time.
To be frank, i realised the bliss of "loving" the subject only after joining IIT:) .. Guess the environment also plays a role in imparting the right orientation towards studies.

manikanta avinash said...

Very good article man. Well-written and well reasoned. You talked about something which is very important and also highly relevant in our country right now. Most of the students in our country do not have the necessary motivation to study as you rightly mentioned. Even teachers and parents are to be blamed for this as they see education as a means to earn money, not as a value in itself.
You had awesome writing skills in high school itself dude! Keep it up.

Abhishek said...

a very nice article indeed.. but somehow I kinda feel the title and the article dont really match.. What I mean to say is, what I dont like studying? Say I love to play sports. I love to act, I love music. Or say I am plainly not interested to study. Then why should I study? I was hoping this article would an answer to that when I saw the title. But it isnt. Its more like.. what is the right way to study?

And even I feel its not easy to adopt what you tell completely. Its because good education comes from a good college. Had you not cared at all about your grades, would you have been here in Stanford. There are so many courses forced down my throat in my life. I did not enjoy doing them but I had to do them as I wanted to be at a better place where I can do what I love in the best way. I guess, this advice is more suitable to someone who is more mature. Probably like us.

voldemort said...

good article

Rahul said...

Awesome dude.... Really wish to revisit my educational life to understand its meaning better.

Still, never late to realise this since at each and every stage, life presents us with an opportunity to learn.

Aashish said...

naice. you wrote so well even then? impressive.

Rakesh Misra said...

@Arun KJ: For someone who changed his major area after undergrad, it's not difficult to see what keeps him going. :-)

@Jasaswee: Thanks for that comment! I agree that classes in the US are a delight, in general - but I guess if the teaching community puts in the effort, it won't be difficult to have something similar back home too. The saddest thing right now is that education in India has become a business where the teachers are changing their teaching styles to meet the demands of the students, when ideally it should have happened the other way round!

@Navneet: Nice comment! I agree completely. :-) [Please have a look at my response to Gudi's comment above]

Rachana said...

Awesome article.... We should all have enjoyed our studies much more than we did. Lets make sure we enjoy further studies and professional careers.

Rakesh Misra said...

@Monika: Thanks! Environment does play a very big role, and that's why I consider myself so lucky to have been at an IIT! :-)

@Manikanta: Thanks! I agree that parents and teachers need to change their outlook, but the question is why should they, given the scenario that exists today? Something needs to be done on a massive scale to be able to change that outlook.

And BTW, I wrote this article only a few days ago - my school is celebrating its silver jubilee this year (2011-12) :-)

Rakesh Misra said...

@Abhishek: I myself bulbed on what to put as the title. Initially, I put it as "Loving your studies", but then I thought "Why Study?" would appeal better to the high school students. Anyway, the title is not a subject of discussion here. ;-) I agree with what you said in your second para, but read my response to Kirtika's comments - I hope you get what I am trying to convey. :-)

@Voldemort, Rahul: Thanks! :-) Ya, better late than never to have this realization. :-)

@Aashish: Na na, I wrote this only recently. 2011-12 is my school's silver jubilee year. :-)

@Rachana: Yes, we will. And let's also help our junior friends in enjoying their studies too. :-)

Saad Bhamla said...

Interesting post.

ankita said...

liked your article..its thought provoking and motivational...but i will tell you what we people were lucky to have had teachers who had actually made our subjects come alive.. relating every tiny detail to the world around us..i hope you get what i mean... the joy of learning..i still do!..,what we feel with all our senses is what we learn..also other than that, beside an inner fire, what actually is the need of the hour are great teachers not just at the professional level but at the elementary level..people whom children can look upto, people who inspire you to reach for the moon.. i am scared that there is a big dearth of good teachers at the school level.. i maybe wrong but i am really apphensive about it..dont know what can be a solution to it.. the best part about ur article is the last stanza of poetry which brought back so many memories...the joy of amalgamating work and passion cannotbe explained by words...it can only be felt...

gRAVIty said...

Great start for the kids. I guess most of our friends have already realized this :). Anyway you made it easy for us to explain it to other people.

ksk_blog said...

Well written article, Rakesh.
A couple of thoughts -
1)This is true for researchers as well, not just for school kids, a fact which is amply clear from the example of Wright brothers. Steve Jobs (who died y'day) is another great example.
2)In a developing country like ours, economics of scoring good percentage in exams invariably come into the picture, irrespective of whether one really enjoys studies or not.(Though this is sad)

Rakesh Misra said...

@Saad: :-)

@Ankita: We were lucky to be in a school where most, if not all, teachers could motivate us to study. But the situation is very bad in an alarmingly large number of schools elsewhere. We indeed have a dearth of good teachers at the junior and higher school levels!

gRAVIty aka Ravikanth: The attempt is to make people think about this at a slightly younger age. :-)

@ksk_blog aka Karthik: Thanks! :-)
(1) Yes - but there the assumption is that the person has himself opted to do research out of his own interest - so it is not hard to motivate him to work (although the motivation levels sometime droop when progress doesn't happen ;-) ).
(2) True, and that has to do with the system of education that exists in our country, where the only way of coming up in life, as Sathish said, is acads->good marks-> a top college-> a high-paying job. Changing the mindset of people isn't easy, and would require a lot of time and effort.

Arvind Ramachandran said...

Lovely article Misre. Echoing some of the earlier comments, the points that you have raised apply not just to academic life, but life in general I guess! The title could very well be "Why Work??" :-)

Anonymous said...

Wow!! Amazing...

The1 said...

I didn't read all the comments above, so sorry to anyone if I have seemingly plagiarised your views.

The one problem with our education system, more than the curricula itself, is the acute lack of good teachers. Teaching is no longer considered a divine-like job and teachers are no longer passionate about what they are doing. And unless you have a motivated teacher taking the subject, no matter how much ever you want to be interested in the subject--you simply wont be!

Second thing is the curricula of many Indian boards. None of them encourage imaginative thinking/small inventions like people. Does any school encourage if one of its students makes an amateur radio? (like Feynmann did?) I dont entirely fault this though, India is a huge nation and the schools can only do so much.

Third is, culturally we are a people who are so reluctant to ask questions. May be the way we are brought up is the reason. For example, as a school kid, will you really question your mom when she says "dont drink tea after eating curd rice"? Its a rule if it comes from an elderly person and not many dare to question it. The same comes to education as well. No one bothers about asking "why" something should work in a specific way, forget "why" they are learning about it in the first place!

So this is a problem thats really hard to solve at the school level. But having said that, I am of a opinion that you really should not be bothered about certain things--on why you are doing it--there are some things worth doing without knowing where they will lead you to. After all, once you understand the reasons, you will realize the magic (hope the last point makes sense!)

PS: Sorry about the long comment.

Harish Ravi said...

Its a very relevant article and I hope that the students pick up from it and try to take time to appreciate what they are learning. Also, we do learn a lot of stuff which probably might not be useful later. However, the students should take initiative and try to find some areas of interest.

Needless to say, a motivated teacher and some demos will go a long way in inspiring them to do this. Also, it would be good if teachers had some access to hands on research in institutes so that they can convey the excitement to students.

Vai_chidrewar said...

Nice article Rakesh. Really loved it.

I think "Three Idiots" also gave the same message. Parents and teachers should also understand this and explain it to students instead of asking them for great results/scores.

Shalin said...

Hey rakesh.. that's the perfect thing that you just wrote. Interestingly drafted and to the point of what the message is.. The point said is really valid. hope someday the education system changes so that everyone gets the benefit. i suppose the government is actively making changes to gets things done correctly. if that would be done sooner, then there would be no need to run abroad or highly ranked institutes.. although everyone would be good in their field of liking and would excel from the point they can think off, even anywhere..

Pallav said...

Very apt and appropriate for students of all ages.. infact questioning "Why?", as Simon Sinek later pointed out in his talk, are the only way for humans to grow..

The post reminds me of a quote: "Education is learning what you didn't even know you didn't know”.
I really feel wish more students can get to read this wonderful article about something that will have such a profound impact on their lives...

Adhiraj said...

Nice article! You make good points, but making school kids realize the importance of _why_ different subjects are taught requires a level of maturity they may not yet have. Instead, teaching in schools should become more 'kid friendly' or interactive - extensive use of technology - say videos and pictures for drab subjects like history would be much more effective in illiciting interest than just telling them 'history is important so that you can appreciate the present via the events of the past'. Bottomline - appeal to a kid's visceral sense of curiosity, rather than his intellect.

Harish Ravi said...

Hey what's with e with all names? Did you just do it because you are from ee